Home  ›  Carriers  ›

Verizon

Info & Phones News Forum  

all discussions

show all 29 replies

bluetooth with obex

svec7186

Feb 24, 2006, 1:12 PM
i'm confused with verizons policies on the bluetooth with obex issue. someone said that obex was disabled due to an agreement with GETITNOW. now i'm hearing that the nokia and razr have functioning obex and also getitnow. whats the deal with disabeling obex only on certain phones????
...
nextel18

Feb 24, 2006, 1:26 PM
that's verizon for you.
...
someone

Feb 25, 2006, 2:33 PM
wow...that was informative and helpful...great response...
...
nextel18

Mar 1, 2006, 10:33 AM
your welcome.. lol.
...
djdelay

Feb 24, 2006, 2:34 PM
here's the deal.....

Nokia forced alot of issues w/ vzw......they required a Nokia interface, and full BT. In order to get full BT and still appease their contract with BREW, they had to restrict the ability to assign your own ringtones that you hadn't downloaded from GetItNow!. I would venture a guess that is also one of the main reasons why it was never supported in Verizon stores.

If I'm not mistaken, the OBEX razrs were a mistake and were meant for alltel. they have since changed them to be the same as the rest of the VzW lineup as far as Bluetooth functionality. Correct me if I'm wrong.
...
wnrussell

Feb 24, 2006, 4:49 PM
djdelay said:
Nokia forced alot of issues w/ vzw......they required a Nokia interface, and full BT. In order to get full BT and still appease their contract with BREW, they had to restrict the ability to assign your own ringtones that you hadn't downloaded from GetItNow!. I would venture a guess that is also one of the main reasons why it was never supported in Verizon stores.

If I'm not mistaken, the OBEX razrs were a mistake and were meant for alltel. they have since changed them to be the same as the rest of the VzW lineup as far as Bluetooth functionality. Correct me if I'm wrong.

You must be right about the RAZR being a mistake, but with the Verizon UI, they could have never been meant for...
(continues)
...
djdelay

Feb 24, 2006, 5:54 PM
wnrussell said:
The whole Bluetooth / GetItNow! conflict is still a mystery. The USB cables and expansion cards allow more file transfer ability, and the GetItNow! files are locked to the ESN and can't be copied to another phone anyway.


This is true, but as it stands now, you cannot transfer your own mp3s and assign them as ringtones on verizon phones. That is more or less what the problem would be with voilating GetItNow!. If you could load your own ringtones, then you wouldn't need to pay for BREW services. That would violate VzW's contract with BREW.
...
wnrussell

Feb 24, 2006, 7:19 PM
djdelay said:
This is true, but as it stands now, you cannot transfer your own mp3s and assign them as ringtones on verizon phones. That is more or less what the problem would be with voilating GetItNow!. If you could load your own ringtones, then you wouldn't need to pay for BREW services. That would violate VzW's contract with BREW.

Right, but you missed my point. Verizon may have a duty to protect BREW services, but closing the door on Bluetooth does not accomplish that, when files are just as readily moved with data cables and expansion cards.

It's like turning off the USB port on the front of a computer, when there are two more on the rear, and thinking you have safeguarded the files someh...
(continues)
...
gunny

Feb 24, 2006, 7:22 PM
wnrussell said

Bluetooth is more restrictive than cable file transfer

Hi wnrussell, how is that?
...
djdelay

Feb 24, 2006, 7:37 PM
I think what he means is that anything you can do with bluetooth, you can build a wired or cabled protocol to do it faster, better, and more reliably.

i.e. - A wireless keyboard won't always connect but a wired one will do so without fail.

what he fails to realize is that you cannot assign ringtones to VzW phns with a data cable unless you use an additional program that is not authorized. the bluetooth cripples also disable this.
...
wnrussell

Feb 24, 2006, 7:54 PM
djdelay said:
what he fails to realize is that you cannot assign ringtones to VzW phns with a data cable unless you use an additional program that is not authorized. the bluetooth cripples also disable this.

Actually, that was my point. You can't transfer GIN files over Bluetooth, but you can over a cable.

So what's the purpose of locking Bluetooth? It's like locking the windows and leaving the front door wide open. How does that make GIN more secure?
...
djdelay

Feb 24, 2006, 8:16 PM
you have to use an unauthorized, warranty voiding program...........let me break it down for ya.........

unauthorized

adj 1: not endowed with authority [syn: unauthorised] [ant: authorized] 2: without official authorization; "an unauthorized strike"; "wildcat work stoppage" [syn: unauthorised, wildcat]¹

Pay close attention to definition number 2. That means that someone figured out a workaround for it. Just because someone got a workaround, should VzW cancel their policy and contract? I think not.






¹- from Dictionary.com
...
wnrussell

Feb 24, 2006, 8:32 PM
djdelay said:
you have to use an unauthorized, warranty voiding program...........let me break it down for ya.........

Not really. The Verizon data cable is not unauthorized, neither is an expansion card, neither is Motorola Mobile Phone Tools, and neither is the Verizon Connection Manager.

You can transfer files using any of those "authorized" products, and maybe more.
...
djdelay

Feb 24, 2006, 9:00 PM
maybe not, but BitPim is.....and that's what you have to use. Not just MPT.
...
wnrussell

Feb 24, 2006, 9:20 PM
Mobile Phone Tools transfers everything Bluetooth does, and with a cable, you can get right to the root folder, which you can not see in 'My Bluetooth Places'. Here is the text, clipped right from the program:
-------------------------------
File Transfer Studio allows you to download your files (images, melodies, videos, applications, etc.) from your mobile phone to your PC and vice versa. Thanks to its user-friendly double-pane view, it allows quick and easy transfer.

Each pane contains tabs where your files are automatically stored according to their types (image, melody or video). Thus, it helps you with the exploration of your mobile phone.

This wizard will show you how to transfer files.

Click on one of the following link ...
(continues)
...
magellan

Mar 4, 2006, 4:07 PM
djdelay said:
maybe not, but BitPim is.....and that's what you have to use. Not just MPT.


Not true.
...
wnrussell

Mar 4, 2006, 4:10 PM
magellan said:
djdelay said:
maybe not, but BitPim is.....and that's what you have to use. Not just MPT.

Not true.

I thought we alrady went over this:

Mobile Phone Tools transfers everything Bluetooth does, and with a cable, you can get right to the root folder, which you can not see in 'My Bluetooth Places'. Here is the text, clipped right from the program:
-------------------------------
File Transfer Studio allows you to download your files (images, melodies, videos, applications, etc.) from your mobile phone to your PC and vice versa. Thanks to its user-friendly double-pane view, it allows quick and easy transfer.

Each pane contains tabs where your files are aut...
(continues)
...
wnrussell

Feb 24, 2006, 7:45 PM
gunny said:
wnrussell said

Bluetooth is more restrictive than cable file transfer

Hi wnrussell, how is that?

Bluetooth folder rights are usually limited to just a few permissions. On a Motorola for example, those would be audio, video, ringtone, picture and mixedmedia.

But with a Radio Shack or Verizon Mobile Office cable, you can open up all of the system folders, the BREW folder, basically the whole phone.

Anybody can copy a GIN-BREW file, but nobody can make that file work on another phone
...
gunny

Feb 24, 2006, 7:59 PM
wnrussell said:
gunny said:
wnrussell said

Bluetooth is more restrictive than cable file transfer

Hi wnrussell, how is that?

Bluetooth folder rights are usually limited to just a few permissions. On a Motorola for example, those would be audio, video, ringtone, picture and mixedmedia.

But with a Radio Shack or Verizon Mobile Office cable, you can open up all of the system folders, the BREW folder, basically the whole phone.

Anybody can copy a GIN-BREW file, but nobody can make that file work on another phone


thank you
...
sowhatsowhat10

Feb 26, 2006, 10:58 AM
the razr does not have obex! 😡 the nokia and e815 were the closest to obex. and the e815 doesnt even support all the files.
...
wnrussell

Feb 26, 2006, 12:43 PM
sowhatsowhat10 said:
the razr does not have obex! 😡 the nokia and e815 were the closest to obex. and the e815 doesnt even support all the files.

The Nokia 6265i supports a full Bluetooth stack.

The E815 and the latest .03 firmware version RAZR have the same Bluetooth profiles as the second firmware (1.40.OR) V710.

The original release RAZR with .02 firmware version supports the Object Exchange profile.
...
sowhatsowhat10

Feb 26, 2006, 5:21 PM
thats where i was getting. i knoew that some earlier razrs supported obex but i was also under the impression that some of the e815's were obex.
...
wnrussell

Feb 26, 2006, 8:07 PM
sowhatsowhat10 said:
thats where i was getting. i knoew that some earlier razrs supported obex but i was also under the impression that some of the e815's were obex.

Only some of the Motorola E815 phones can be 'hacked' to have OBject EXchange. None of them came with it out of the box, except in Canada.
...
sdgmcdon

Mar 1, 2006, 12:46 PM
My understanding is that it's disabled on any phone that Verizon sells in their store. I bought the Nokia 6256i from Best Buy and BT OBEX works fine.

Personally I don't buy the "get it now" contracts BS - That's a piss poor excuse for them looking at BT OBEX and saying "wow, that's really cool, now, how can we charge people for that? I GOT IT! Lets disable it and create our own "service" to replace it!".

Bastards
...
wnrussell

Mar 4, 2006, 8:42 AM
sdgmcdon said:
My understanding is that it's disabled on any phone that Verizon sells in their store. I bought the Nokia 6256i from Best Buy and BT OBEX works fine.

Personally I don't buy the "get it now" contracts BS - That's a piss poor excuse for them looking at BT OBEX and saying "wow, that's really cool, now, how can we charge people for that? I GOT IT! Lets disable it and create our own "service" to replace it!".

If the GIN contracts really do ban Bluetooth, then they should also ban data cables, charging ports and expansion cards because it's just as easy to transfer files through those ports and devices.

I think the GIN BT ban must be a hoax. Verizon is supporting Bluetooth tethering for $60...
(continues)
...
dave73

Mar 4, 2006, 11:47 AM
wnrussell said:
I think the GIN BT ban must be a hoax. Verizon is supporting Bluetooth tethering for $60 a month now.

If you're referring to BT tethering for modem use, that is still crippled on their phones. You have to use a data cable for that. It's going to be a while before Verizon fully supports bluetooth. For now, only expect them to support the headset profiles.
...
wnrussell

Mar 4, 2006, 2:40 PM
dave73 said:
wnrussell said:
I think the GIN BT ban must be a hoax. Verizon is supporting Bluetooth tethering for $60 a month now.

If you're referring to BT tethering for modem use, that is still crippled on their phones. You have to use a data cable for that. It's going to be a while before Verizon fully supports bluetooth. For now, only expect them to support the headset profiles.

Well, the new BroadBandAccess tethering plan became real on 2.6.2006. Read this:

http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,1895,1918150,00.asp »

The service is $59.99 per month, unlimited, and does everything your cable access can do. I Really like it.

Quote:

Verizon Wireless has changed it...
(continues)
...
sdgmcdon

Mar 6, 2006, 12:21 PM
I think that is a problem as well though. BT tethering should work FOR FREE...it's an included function of the phone from the manufacturer that VZW is tinkering with so that they can charge for it.
...
Eviltwin19

Mar 4, 2006, 9:30 PM
Today i figured out that my palm treo 650 cant send anything by bluetooth. I really dont want to switch to T-mobile just for that function.

Can some one tell me are there any verizon phones that support Obex

Also if i get the Alltel Razor will i have fully functional bluetooth

thanks
...
wnrussell

Mar 4, 2006, 9:47 PM
Eviltwin19 said:
Can some one tell me are there any verizon phones that support Obex

Also if i get the Alltel Razor will i have fully functional bluetooth

Only the Nokia 6256i and the V3c RAZR with the original .02 firmware support OBject EXchange.

Verizon stripped the file transfer from the RAZR phones that were made after Christmas so you can't load your own ringtones.
...

You must log in to reply.

Please log in to report a message to the moderator.


all discussions

Subscribe to Phone Scoop News with RSS Follow @phonescoop on BlueSky Follow @phonescoop on Mastodon Follow @phonescoop on Threads Phone Scoop on Facebook

 

Playwire

All content Copyright 2001-2025 Phone Factor, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Content on this site may not be copied or republished without formal permission.